I believe Peyton Manning is a great athlete and a great competitor, but when it comes to quality of life, I think he should just shut it down. When you are dealing with neck issues, that's a lot different from an ankle or hand. This is something that could really effect your play and quality of life. I'm a huge EAGLES fan, but I wouldn't want to see Peyton go to the Skins' and get hurt. What are your thoughts?

Man, this is not a tough call for me. Manning's injuries are a red flag. He's getting older, and the Redskins should try to get better than aging superstars. Remember that rough 2010 season with Donovan McNabb at the helm?

I'm just concerned about his quality of life. What else does he have to prove? He's been a league mvp and won a Super Bowl. But I'm certain the Redskins will find a way to give him $45 million only to see him not do well in the Shanahan system. It's the Redskin way to pay millions and get minimum results. We'll see what happens in the days to come.

This is a tough call because the team has been burned bringing in QB's near the end of their career. I'm in love with RG3 and think he's a big time talent that could solve our QB issues for the next decade or so. No matter which way the team goes I hope Shanny and Son get it right!

I agree that the Skins' have a history of bringing in guys at the end of their career, but this is different. He's injured his neck and that could come back and bite whoever picks him up. Great athlete, just at the point he needs to think retirement. As for RG3, he's a stud but who do the Skins' have to block for him? It's a lost cause to bring him in. They should draft defense and offensive line and pick up another QB in free agency.

I'm going to send you an email.

This is a no brainer! Despite the fact I'm a lifelong Eagles fan Manning should have the 'Skins phone # on "call block!" Manning has always been in complete control of his offense and I can't see him submitting to Kyle Shanahan's "anyone can fit my scheme" offense. And let's not forget the "matador style" blocking of the past few seasons. Manning moves nowhere near as well as McNabb, Grossman, Beck, or Campbell. He'd be on IR after 5 games. Run Peyton, run as far away from DC as you can get!

Chuck, you're alright in my book! Always a pleasure to meet fellow Eagles fans (not on the wagon, I was born and raised in Philly). I agree Manning shouldn't come to DC, but I'm one who believes he should hang up the clears.

While I think Peyton is a class act and a very talented athlete. I think he needs to seriously think about his health and his family. I'm sure he has the competitive fire burning within, but after all those surgeries, I would be concerned about a hit to that area which could lead to something far worse for him.

The Redskins need a QB but they also need quality receivers and quality corners as well. I'm all about rebuilding and if it takes time so be it. Hell, we haven't done much since Danny Boy took over.

This can't be Shanahan wanting Manning. This has the "shiny new object syndrome" of Snyder.

Manning's already told the Redskins he's not coming here so we can forget about him as an option here in D.C.

RG3 would be nice, but he's not worth sacrificing our entire draft, plus some of next year's, to trade up to the number two pick. i honestly think bringing in manning, which would almost guarantee also bringing in reggie wayne, pierre garcon, jeff saturday, and pretty much every other talented colt left on their roster, would make the redskins a contender. he did say he doesn't want to play here though, so i think that ship has sailed. that being said, we have needs pretty much everywhere, so i think our best option is to draft the best non-QB/RB available - could be justin blackmon or morris claiborne - and stick with rex grossman again this year. then next year, assuming we're at the top of the draft again, we make a play for matt barkley, or possibly landry jones, although i'm not sold on jones the way i am on barkley.